Saildrone, Blue Water Autonomy Ruling Adds Restrictions to OTA Funding Model
PARIS — An acquisition tool that the Pentagon has recently favored now comes with more strings attached following a late October ruling from a federal judge on a Navy drone boat program. Judge Philip Hadji, who sits on the Federal Court of Claims, asserts the court is a venue to challenge Other Transaction Authorities, providing a check against OTA awards from the Pentagon, according to the Oct. 30 ruling that was unsealed last week. Other transaction authority, an acquisition tool developed during the space race, has been the funding tool of choice for rapid acquisition across the Defense Department. Under
Saildrone Spectre rendering. Saildrone image PARIS — An acquisition tool that the Pentagon has recently favored now comes with more strings attached following a late October ruling from a federal judge on a Navy drone boat program.
Judge Philip Hadji, who sits on the Federal Court of Claims, asserts the court is a venue to challenge Other Transaction Authorities, providing a check against OTA awards from the Pentagon, according to the Oct. 30 ruling that was unsealed last week.
Other transaction authority, an acquisition tool developed during the space race, has been the funding tool of choice for rapid acquisition across the Defense Department. Under OTAs, the Navy has acquired everything from landing ships to software craft requirements that aren’t covered by the Federal Acquisition Regulation. Functionally, it means the Pentagon isn’t required to announce OTAs or disclose the amount of the awards, unlike traditional contracts.
“OTAs rely on DoD contracting officials to customize the terms and conditions they deem necessary to protect the government’s interests. This flexibility may help DoD attract nontraditional defense contractors that otherwise may not choose to contract with DoD,” reads a 2025 Government Accountability Office report on the tool.
From 2016 to 2024, OTAs grew from $1.8 billion to $18 billion as more prototyping efforts have shifted to the funding model, according to the GAO. The Trump Administration has increased OTAs as part of an overall push for rapid acquisition.
For example, venture capital-backed shipbuilder Saronic has been awarded OTAs for small and medium robotic surface craft and for the traditional LCU-1700 landing ship program.
The Navy’s MUSV program is $2.1 billion and will be funded with OTAs.
Until the ruling, there was no clear venue to challenge the government’s awards.
The case brought by MUSV makers Saildrone and Blue Water Autonomy argued the Navy did not follow its own criteria in how it picked contenders for the MUSV program that used OTAs. As part of the ruling, Hadji found that the Federal Court of Claims has the authority to hear cases protesting an award that would lead to a full program.
Hadji ruled in favor of Saildrone but upheld the Navy’s decision not to advance Blue Water Autonomy.
He said the court “has broad procurement protest jurisdiction over any objection to a solicitation, proposed award, award, or alleged violation of statute or regulation ‘in connection with a procurement or proposed procurement,’ which includes ‘all stages of the process of acquiring property or services, beginning with the process for determining a need for property or services.”
Saildrone will now be reevaluated for the MUSV effort and Hadji ordered a status report on the overall program in 90 days.
“The future of naval warfare will be fought on the water, not in a courtroom,” said Saildrone CEO Richard Jenkins in a statement. ”We are eager to move beyond this litigation and return our entire focus to delivering world-leading maritime autonomy for the US Navy, to help secure America’s future maritime dominance. This ruling is a win for fair competition, for taxpayers, and for national security.”
In a statement, Blue Water Autonomy founder Austin Gray told USNI News, “Blue Water and Saildrone won this argument. This argument was one of three that Blue Water had to win in order to drive corrective action by the Navy.”
What the ruling will do is place more scrutiny on the process, a budget expert with the American Enterprise Institute told USNI News.
“Expansion of bid protest jurisdiction on OTAs at the Federal Court of Claims has a significant potential to destroy OTA authority as a fast alternative to developing new capabilities,” American Enterprise Institute’s Bill Greenwalt told USNI News last month. “At the same time the services contracting organizations seem to think they can load up OTAs with all sorts of traditional [regulation] type clauses, mandates, criteria and requirements and still call it an OTA so they can get a pass by being perceived as being exempt from the protest process.”
The ruling is a recognition that the Navy can’t use OTAs without scrutiny, Greenwalt said.
“Having the [court] slap down the Navy may be productive if it leads to a return to how OTAs are supposed to work by bringing non-traditionals into the market,” he said. “If Navy contracting officers are using the authority as a ruse to eventually award to traditional contractors, which is a distinct possibility in this procurement, then they deserve to be called out on the carpet.”
In a statement to USNI News, the Pentagon said they were aware of the ruling.
“We are aware of the Court of Federal Claims’ ruling in the Blue Water Autonomy/Saildrone matter. The litigation is pending with the Department of Justice and the Department of Navy. We do not comment on ongoing litigation. The Department will review the matter and develop next steps once the litigation is resolved,” reads a statement from a Pentagon spokesperson.
The case has been resolved, but the Defense Department could appeal the ruling. A spokesperson did not respond if the Pentagon would appeal when asked by USNI News.
The ruling comes as OTAs have received increasing criticism in academic circles.
“If lawmakers don’t narrow the authority, they risk sleepwalking the American people into a generation of Pentagon boondoggles,” wrote Julia Gledhill of the Stimson Center in Breaking Defense last month.
Non-traditional defense companies continue to defend the OTA model as effective over the bureaucratic process of Pentagon acquisition, which is governed by the Federal Acquisition Regulation.
“We should just go back to 100 [percent] FAR-based contracts. …said no-one ever,” Blue Water Autonomy founder Gray said in a post on X.