Royal Navy Lacks Ships, Capabilities to Defend High North from Russia, Says U.K. Committee Report
The Royal Navy currently lacks the ships and capabilities needed to defend the High North from Russia, the bipartisan House of Commons Defense Committee warned on Thursday. In its “Defense in the High North” report issued on Thursday, the committee described the Royal Navy as being plagued by shipbuilding delays, maintenance backlogs and an atrophying submarine force. “The U.K. needs to be willing to address a hard truth: it does not currently have all the capabilities to operate successfully in the High North. Russian submarine and sabotage forces in the High North pose direct risks to the North Atlantic and
A Russian Kilo-class submarine in the High North, observed by Standing NATO Maritime Group 1 (SNMG1), released by NATO on Oct. 26, 2026. NATO photo The Royal Navy currently lacks the ships and capabilities needed to defend the High North from Russia, the bipartisan House of Commons Defense Committee warned on Thursday.
In its “Defense in the High North” report issued on Thursday, the committee described the Royal Navy as being plagued by shipbuilding delays, maintenance backlogs and an atrophying submarine force.
“The U.K. needs to be willing to address a hard truth: it does not currently have all the capabilities to operate successfully in the High North. Russian submarine and sabotage forces in the High North pose direct risks to the North Atlantic and the U.K., including the nuclear deterrent. Despite this, the Ministry of Defense has accepted a serious anti-submarine warfare gap. Publicly available evidence of low availability among destroyers, frigates and attack submarines calls into question whether the U.K. can meet its commitments in the High North,” said Tan Dhesi, chair of the defense committee and a Labor Party member of Parliament.
The report put 2030 as the deadline for the U.K. to be militarily ready to deter or defeat a Russian threat, citing then-Prime Minister Keir Starmer’s statement in June that there could be an attack by Russia on NATO as soon as 2030, according to an assessment by the U.K. and allied intelligence services.
“If the U.K. government means what it says – that Russia could attack NATO as soon as 2030 – then work to rectify these vulnerabilities cannot start soon enough,” Dhesi said.
The U.K. Defense Investment Plan released in June committed to investing £298 billion – $397.9 billion – across the next four years to reach 2.7 percent of gross domestic product (GDP) spent on defense by 2030. The committee noted an internal document drawn up by NATO to measure how effectively members are meeting their rearmament promises. The U.K. was at number 31 out of 32 Alliance countries, according to the committee report.
HMS Dragon sails into His Majesty’s Naval Base Portsmouth on Oct. 9, 2026. UK Ministry of Defense photo “Only Iceland, a country with no military capability, is lower on the table,” reads the committee report.
The Royal Navy’s anti-submarine warfare frigates and nuclear-powered submarines offer the greatest deterrent to Russian activities in the High North, however both are aging or unavailable due to maintenance issues. Additionally, the Royal Navy established in 2010 a requirement for a fleet of six destroyers and 13 frigates but has struggled to meet this requirement. The current fleet consists of six Type 45 destroyers and five Type 23 frigates – barely half of the requirement for a 19 ship fleet.
“Although new frigates will eventually join the fleet in sufficient numbers, the current fleet readiness picture raises doubts about whether the U.K. could sustain the maritime tasks required in the High North by 2030,” reads the report.
Particularly critical to the capabilities needed in the High North is the requirement for eight of the 13 frigates to be fitted with the Sonar 2087 towed array to undertake anti-submarine warfare operations. The towed array is currently on all the remaining five Type 23s.
The slow construction and delivery of the Type 26s has led to a capability gap in the Royal Navy’s ASW frigate numbers. The first-in-class Type 26 was laid down in 2017 and is scheduled to be accepted in 2027. Eight Type 26 frigates will take over the ASW role in the future with five Type 31 general purpose ships making up the remaining frigate requirement.
The ASW frigates could be as low as five for the next three years, according to the committee. Two of the under construction Royal Navy Type 26s will be sold to meet Norway’s 2025 order – to be in service by 2039 – which means the Royal Navy won’t meet its eight ASW frigate requirement until 2037.
The Defense Committee recommended that no more Type 23s should leave service until they are replaced on a one-for-one basis by the Type 26.
Tugs spray water as aircraft carrier HMS Prince of Wales (R09) approaches Rounds Tower in England, Nov. 30, 2025. Royal Navy photo The Royal Navy has also faced challenges in maintaining its destroyers, aircraft carriers, amphibious ships and submarines, all of which can provide military capabilities useful for High North operations, the Defense Committee said.
Both the Royal Navy’s Queen Elizabeth-class carriers broke down in 2022 and 2024 due to propeller shaft issues. The Royal Navy’s two specialist amphibious assault ships were decommissioned in November of 2024 ahead of their planned inactivation dates of 2033 and 2034. The U.K. and the Netherlands have since signed a contract to procure a fleet of four amphibious vessels each, but these are unlikely to be in service until the 2030s.
Destroyer HMS Dragon (D35) was pulled out of maintenance in March to deploy to Cyprus to defend against drone attacks.
“The fact that no other destroyer was ready to deploy from the fleet of Type 45 vessels may reflect the lack of deployable ships. As these platforms provide air defense, they would be equally important in any High North operation,” said the Defense Committee.
In addition, all five Astute-class nuclear attack submarines were all recently tied up in dockyards at the same time, with none deployed. The Defense Committee also pointed to the atrophying of the Royal Navy’s submarine capability and questioned its ability to operate under the ice.
Astute-class nuclear submarine HMS Ambush. UK Royal Navy photo “Without a credible under-ice capability, the U.K. is less able to contest Russian freedom of action in the High North and risks being forced into a more defensive posture. Russia can then use the ice to conceal and protect its own submarines, while threatening NATO sea lanes, U.K. critical infrastructure and the nuclear deterrent,” said the Defense Committee.
The report recommended that the government provide the Defense Committee with a plan outlining how the Ministry of Defense will improve the availability of the Royal Navy’s frigates, destroyers and attack submarines before 2030. This update may be presented at a classified level, but the committee will expect a version to be publicly available.
The Defense Committee report calls for the government to brief its progress to re-establish an under-ice capability for at least some of the Astute-class submarines.
Regarding the U.K.’s Hybrid Navy program, the committee said it is not convinced that the £1.3 billion – or $1.7 billion USD – allocated for the program will be sufficient. While the committee encourages the pursuit of naval exports, it said the government needs to ensure that the exports did not compete with the U.K.’s own requirements for scarce ships, systems and skilled labor.
The allocated funds cover the procurement of five vessel types – the Type 91 uncrewed missile platform, Type 92 uncrewed sloop with underwater sensors, Type 93 extra-large uncrewed underwater vessels (XLUUVs), Type 94 uncrewed radar platforms and a future class of crewed Common Combat Vessels (CCV). The report calls on the government to set out the basis on which it judges the current funding allocation to be adequate.
The Defense Committee said that defense exports can strengthen the U.K.’s position in the High North when they help closely aligned allies field capabilities that are interoperable with the Royal Navy and are suited to northern operations. The Type 26 agreement with Norway could expand NATO’s ASW capacity on the northern flank and deepen U.K.-Norwegian operational and industrial integration. However, the report said export success must not come at the expense of the Royal Navy’s own Type 26 frigate delivery timelines.
“The government must ensure that naval exports expand industrial capacity and allied capability, rather than competing with U.K. requirements for scarce ships, systems and skilled labor,” reads the Defense Committee report.
In contrast, the committee said the Royal Marines capabilities for High North operations were excellent, due to its expertise from regular deployments to Northern Norway, logistic capabilities and the Commando Helicopter Force. However, the Royal Marines can’t compensate for the naval platforms’ shortfalls.